This chapter was very interesting to me. I really liked the comparison between Piaget and Vygotsky's theories. I think, for myself, I tend to blend both of them together. I think of the stages of development of Piaget and combine it with the zone of proximal development of Vygotsky. Both theories have good aspects, but I believe in a combination.
I wonder why the zone of proximal development (ZPD) has become so popular. The ZPD states that students will be able to do the activity with the help of an adult without getting frustrated or bored (because it was too easy). It makes sense to do instructional activities this way to yield great results. This reminds me of what Brother Osguthorpe said in his power of teaching lecture. He said that it is our responsibility to teach students to do somethings that they don't want to (for reasons of difficulty), because we know that it would be good for them.
Both Piaget and Vygotsky feel that pretend play is very important for child development. What kind of confused me for a minute was why Vygotsky said that individual pretend play is also a social interaction. How can doing an activity by yourself be a social interaction? Then, I though of imaginary friends. Children who have imaginary friends treat them as if they were real, breathing human beings. Thus, they are socially interacting with their imaginary friend and gaining social skills.
I really could see the valid application of these theories in some aspects. "[Linking] new concepts to students' prior knowledge" just seems like common sense to me. This reminds me of when we talked about transfer in class. According to the different theories, people will associate new experiences with what they already know. For example, a student may see a whale and call it a fish. They do this because they already know what a fish is (a sea creature with fins and swims) and apply the same characteristics or knowledge about a fish to a whale. Later on, they may reconstruct meaning. I feel that this is important for us to know to be able to teach so that students will understand and remember new material.
1 year old!
10 years ago